Elasticsearch vs SQL Server - Key Differences

Comparative analysis of different database systems can help you narrow down a database ideal for data management and analysis tasks. This article compares Elasticsearch vs SQL Server and helps you to understand the functionality of each of these databases. 

Elasticsearch and MS SQL Server are two highly popular database systems used for specific purposes. Elasticsearch is used for near-real-time data analysis and search functions, while SQL Server is used for OLTP transactional purposes. This guide will help you decide whether to use Elasticsearch or SQL Server for data-related operations. 

What is Elasticsearch?

Elasticsearch is an analytics and search engine with distributed architecture and is built on the Apache Lucene library. It allows you to store, search, and query various data types, including string, integer, boolean, float, date, and binary data.

To ingest data in Elasticsearch, you can use Elastic Beats, Logstash, language clients, or Kibana Dev tools. The ingested data is stored in JSON documents, and a searchable reference can be added to these documents in the cluster’s index. Since the data is stored in a schema-free JSON format, it can be retrieved quickly. You can then analyze and visualize the data using Kibana, a visualization and reporting tool for preparing interactive data visualizations.

In addition to these capabilities, Elasticsearch can also be used as a vector database to generate and store vector embeddings. You can integrate it with LLMs to get accurate output for queries. 

Key Features of Elasticsearch

Some key features of Elasticsearch are as follows:

• Analytics: Elasticsearch allows you to perform near-real-time data analytics using its aggregation capabilities, Graph Explore API, and threshold value-based alerting mechanism.
• Search Capabilities: You can utilize Elasticsearch for full-text search, a technique for finding specific words or phrases within documents, databases, or websites. 
• Scalability: Elasticsearch enables you to distribute querying and searching tasks across an Elasticsearch cluster, which is a group of two or more nodes. As the data volume increases, you can add additional nodes to this cluster to distribute the data across multiple nodes. 
• Cross-cluster Replication: This feature enables you to replicate indices from a remote cluster into your local cluster. This reduces network latency and helps recover from any disaster caused by the primary cluster's failure. 
• Robust Security Mechanism: Elasticsearch provides effective security features that enable you to secure your data within clusters. You can protect your data using passwords or leverage more advanced security features such as role-based access control, auditing, encryption, and IP filtering.

What is MS SQL Server?

Microsoft SQL Server is a relational database management system that helps you store data in tabular format. The table consists of rows and columns(attributes), where you can store data records related to each other in an organized manner.

SQL Server can be deployed on Windows, Linux, or Azure Virtual Machine. To query data, SQL Server uses its database engine. It is the primary component of data storage and processing. This database engine enables you to query data on different storage architectures, including local tables, tables distributed across multiple servers, and partition tables. You can execute your queries using row or batch execution mode according to your preferences. 

Key Features of MS SQL Server

Here are some important features of MS SQL Server:

• Data Management and Storage: SQL Server enables you to handle related data records and perform complex queries using SQL. 
• Security: This database ensures data security by providing encryption, restricted access, and authentication mechanisms. 
• Data Availability: It supports Failover Clustering, Always On Availability Groups, and Database Mirroring to ensure high availability and minimize downtime.
• Analytics: You can integrate data from diverse sources into a SQL Server. This data can then be processed and analyzed to generate meaningful insights. 

Key Differences Between Elasticsearch vs SQL Server

According to the StackOverflow survey, 25.3% & 12.5% of developers use SQL Server & Elasticsearch, respectively. Let us understand some key factors that differentiate Elasticsearch vs SQL Server performance:

Database Model

Elasticsearch is a NoSQL database with a distributed architecture. It uses a JSON-based document-oriented database model and allows you to store data in schema-free format. This imparts flexibility and facilitates the handling of semi-structured and structured data.

MS SQL Server, on the other hand, is an RDBMS where you can store data in tabular format based on fixed schema. Due to such rigidity, this database is useful for handling structured data records with defined relationships. 

Scalability

Elasticsearch supports the sharding technique. This technique involves increasing a cluster’s capacity by adding more nodes to it and distributing the incoming data load for efficient processing.

In contrast, SQL Server achieves scalability by implementing multiple threads to persist changes to memory-optimized tables. You can also implement sharding and replication to improve its scalability. 

Performance

With Elasticsearch, you can utilize its inverted indexing for text searches and quick data retrieval. However, complex, transactional queries involving joins or relationships between tables significantly impact its performance.

Alternatively, SQL Server is optimized to process complex queries on structured and relational data and provide quick response times. You can maximize its performance by increasing the efficiency of CPU usage, disk I/O, and network traffic. 

Pricing Model

Elasticsearch is open-source software, and there are no licensing charges if you choose the self-hosted version. However, its managed cloud service offers four pricing tiers: Standard starting at $95/month; Gold at $109/month; Platinum at $125/month; and Enterprise at $175/month. 

Conversely, SQL Server is proprietary software that provides various licensing options, such as subscriptions for cloud deployments and server + Client Access Licenses (CAL). It has a pay-as-you-go model where the cost depends on several factors, like the number of cores and the type of edition (Standard, Web, or Enterprise). SQL Server also offers two free versions—Developer and Express.

Tabular Comparison Between SQL Server vs Elasticsearch

Here is a tabular comparison of SQL Server vs Elasticsearch:

Factors to Consider When Choosing Elasticsearch or MS SQL Server

Some of the important factors that you should consider while selecting Elasticsearch or MS SQL Server are as follows:

Integration with Your Current Infrastructure

You should explore the various integration options offered by each of these database systems and how easily you can incorporate them into your current ecosystem. SQL Server offers robust integration facilities such as linked servers and ODBC and JDBC drivers. 

Elasticsearch also offers numerous integration options, such as REST API, web crawler, and data connectors. This platform is more accessible due to its open-source nature. However, if you have a Microsoft-heavy infrastructure, you can lean towards SQL Server.

Indexing

Indexing is a crucial aspect of your database’s performance. While Elasticsearch and SQL Server both employ indexing techniques, they take different approaches. In Elasticsearch, index is a storage unit for documents, which consist of key-value pairs. Elasticsearch uses an inverted index structure, useful for performing full-text searches on denormalized data. 

Conversely, an index in SQL Server contains keys made from one or more columns in the table. These keys help with faster data retrieval, but this method is inefficient for unstructured data. The other types of indexing supported by SQL Server include clustered, non-clustered, and hash.

Depending on the type of data you are dealing with, you can recognize which indexing technique works faster and choose the platform accordingly.  

Vector Data Storage

You can use Elasticsearch as a vector database as it allows you to generate and store vector embeddings, while SQL Server does not support vector data. As a result, if you want to work with vector data, you can opt for Elasticsearch and integrate it with the LLM of your choice to improve the query outcomes. 

Use Cases or Applications

Some of the use cases where you can leverage Elasticsearch include:

• Analyzing Log and Event Data: With Elasticsearch, you can store and analyze application logs, web server logs, and network events. This helps you identify any hidden patterns or trends and troubleshoot issues. 
• Data Observability: You can use Elasticsearch’s real-time search and analysis capabilities to monitor network traffic and data from sources such as metrics and traces. It is a complete observability solution with visualizations and an alert mechanism. 

Some of the applications of SQL Server include:

• Web-based Platforms: SQL Server follows a client-server model and is best suited for e-commerce platforms, content management systems (CMS), and other web applications to manage high-volume user data and transactions. 
• Data Warehousing: You can implement various optimization techniques supported by SQL Server like partitioning and indexing to facilitate small to medium-sized data warehousing.   

Experience Seamless Elasticsearch or SQL Server Data Integration with Airbyte

To leverage the effective features of Elasticsearch or MS SQL Server, you can integrate data from your desired source system into these databases. You can use Airbyte, an effective data integration platform, to simplify this integration process.

Airbyte helps you collect and consolidate data from various sources in a unified repository. It offers a vast library of 400+ connectors that facilitates data integration into Elasticsearch or MS SQL Server according to your requirements. You can also load data from Elasticsearch to MS SQL Server with the help of these pre-built connectors.

Some important features of Airbyte are as follows:

• Change Data Capture: The change data capture (CDC) feature of Airbyte allows you to capture incremental changes made at the source system and reflect them in the target system. This helps in keeping source and destination data systems in sync with each other. 
• Build Developer-Friendly Pipeline: PyAirbyte is a Python library supported by Airbyte that allows you to extract data from different source systems using Airbyte-supported connectors. 
• Flexibility to Develop Custom Connectors: Airbyte enables you to build custom connectors through its Connector Builder, Low Code Connector Development Kit (CDK), Python CDK, and Java CDK.
• Data Pipeline Orchestration: You can orchestrate your data workflows by integrating Airbyte with data orchestration tools like Apache Airflow, Dagster, Kestra, or Prefect. 

Conclusion

MS SQL Server and Elasticsearch both are used in different scenarios because of their unique features. If you want to perform full-text search and analytics on semi-structured and unstructured data, you can use Elasticsearch. Alternatively, you can use SQL Server if you want to work with structured data and manage OLTP transactions. This blog gives a detailed description of Elasticsearch vs SQL Server differences to help you understand which database is suitable to fulfill your data objectives.

‍