Data Backup vs. Replication: Optimal Use Cases & Tools

•

March 22, 2024

•

20 min read

Data loss is everyone’s worst nightmare. Imagine working countless hours on a critical document, only to have a computer crash wipe it all away. Similarly, this data loss can be equally disastrous for your business, leading to lost work, missed deadlines, and even legal repercussions. Two critical tools exist to safeguard your valuable information—data backup and replication. Both mechanisms, backups stored off-site and replicated copies in different locations, contribute to data protection by providing extra layers of security against data loss or corruption. These measures significantly minimize the risk of complete data loss.

While both methods aim to protect your data, they operate in distinct ways. Choosing the right approach depends on your specific needs. This guide will dissect the strengths and limitations of each method and equip you with the knowledge to select the best tools for your data pipeline.

What is Data Backup?

Data backup is a copy of your data that is stored in a separate location from the original. This copy can restore your data if the original is lost, damaged, or corrupted. Data backup can be implemented to protect your essential information, such as documents, photos, videos, or audio files. These can be stored on-site, such as on an external hard drive or off-site, in the cloud.

Data backups can be executed in different forms, including:

Full Backup: It is the most comprehensive and straightforward method. You can create a complete copy of all your data at a specific point in time. Think of it like photocopying an entire book. ‍
Incremental Backup: In this method, you only back up the changed data since you last copied it. Like you’re only photocopying the pages in the book that have new information.

What is Data Replication?

Data replication is a process of creating and maintaining multiple copies of your data in different locations. This is primarily done to improve data availability, reliability, and resilience rather than solely for disaster recovery purposes like backups. Data replication complements data backups by providing a readily available copy for immediate use in case of distributions, while backups serve as a long-term archive for full data recovery after incidents.

Different types of data replication processes include:

Synchronous Replication: Updates are applied to all copies simultaneously, guaranteeing consistent data across all locations. However, this can impact performance due to the need for synchronization and waiting for all replicas to acknowledge the update.‍
Asynchronous Replication: This method applies updates to the source first and then propagates to replicas later. This offers better performance but can lead to temporary inconsistencies between the source and replicas until all updates are caught up. ‍
Semi-synchronous Replication: This is a hybrid approach in which updates are first applied to the source and then acknowledged by a certain number of copies before proceeding. Semi-synchronous replication ensures balanced data consistency and performance.

Data Backup vs Replication: Major Comparison

Both data backup and replication are crucial data protection strategies, but they serve distinct purposes and have different characteristics. Here’s a breakdown of their key differences

Features	Data Backup	Data Replication
Purpose	It aims to create a copy of data at specific points in time that can be used to restore lost or corrupted data later.	It aims to maintain multiple, synchronized copies of data in different locations to ensure continuous access even if the primary source becomes unavailable.
Functionality	You can create periodic copies of data and store them separately, often offline or offsite.	Allows you to continuously synchronize data updates from a source location to one or more replicas in different locations.
Benefits	Specific for data loss and recovery at a specific point in time.	Minimizes downtime, improves fault tolerance, and enhances performance.
Use Cases	Long-term archival, regulatory compliance requirements, and protection against accidental deletion.	Mission-critical applications, disaster recovery, and reducing latency.
Data Consistency	High (guaranteed consistency at the point of backup)	Varies depending on the type of replication
Performance	Lower due to the overhead of copying and storing data.	Higher, especially for read workloads distributed across replicas.
Storage Requirements	The storage requirements are lower as it only stores the historical data backups.	Has higher storage requirements as multiple copies of data are stored.
Cost	Generally lower, especially for simple backup solutions.	The cost is generally higher due to the complexity of managing and maintaining replicas.

Data Replication vs Data Backup: Use Cases

So far, you have seen how data replication and backup are suited for distinct use cases. Let’s see some specific examples.

Use Case of Data Replication

E-commerce websites experience high volumes of traffic during peak shopping seasons like Black Friday or Cyber Monday. To ensure that the website remains accessible and responsive, using the replication is the best option. By this, you can replicate data to geographically distributed servers.
An airline reservation utilizes data replication to synchronize passenger information and flight details across multiple servers. This ensures that reservation agents and travelers can access real-time data regardless of server location or potential outages.

Use Case of Data Backup

In healthcare, patients' medical records are backed up regularly. They are stored securely and comply with HIPAA regulations regarding patient data privacy.
Regular code repositories and project file backups are essential in software development. This approach safeguards developers' work against accidental deletion, software malfunctions, or unforeseen circumstances.

Data Backup vs Data Replication: Tools

While backup and replication tasks can be done manually, there are scenarios when automation becomes necessary. Therefore, to streamline these processes, you can consider using the following tools.

Airbyte

Airbyte is a data integration and replication platform that helps you transfer data from multiple sources to a destination. With its 350+ pre-built connectors, you can seamlessly move your data segregated at different origins to a unified location. In addition, it also allows you to enable the Change Data Capture (CDC) technique to effectively capture the changes since the last replication and maintain synchronized replicas of your data in various locations.

Key features of Airbyte include:

Airbyte allows scheduling data replications at regular intervals, ensuring data is synchronized periodically.
With Airbyte, you can also take backups of your existing files or databases and update them regularly as the source data appends, all without any manual interventions. For instance, if you have website data stored in MySQL, you can create a copy of this data in another instance of the database.
For situations like batch data replication, Airbyte leverages log-based CDC. It continuously monitors the secure database’s transaction logs, capturing changes as they occur and replicating them to the destination. This minimizes resource utilization while replicating data between the source and the replica.
It allows you to leverage dbt, a data transformation tool that enables modifications in data after the replication process, ensuring the information at the destination is in the desired format.
Airbyte supports secure connections with source and destination systems using SSL/TLS and SSH tunneling.

Acronis Cyber Protect Home Office

Acronis Cyber Protect Home Office is a software suite designed to provide comprehensive cyber protection for your home and office environment. It was formerly known as Acronis True Image. Acronis combines data backup and cybersecurity functionalities, offering a one-stop solution for safeguarding your digital assets.

Features of Acronis include:

It creates full copies of your system disk or partitions so that you can quickly recover the entire system or single files/folders.
Acronis builds clones on Windows or MacOS without interruption, facilitating seamless data migration to larger or faster disks, encompassing files, apps, and settings.
The backups are safeguarded on-site, in transit, and in the cloud by enterprise-grade AES-256 encryption.

Azure Backup

Azure Backup is a cloud-based backup service offered by Microsoft Azure. It provides a secure, scalable, cost-effective way to recover your data in Microsoft Cloud. With AzureBackup, you can proactively protect your critical business systems by creating backups that can be easily restored in case of data loss or accidental deletion. It additionally provides an extra security layer to your backup environment when your data is in transit and at rest.

The key functionalities of Azure Backup are:

Azure Backup offers integrated alerting and monitoring features within a Recovery Service Vault.
With Azure Backup, you can create backup policies to schedule regular backups of your data and applications, ensuring you have copies available for recovery in case of data loss.
Azure-enhanced soft delete feature provides you with the ability to recover your data even after it is deleted, accidentally or maliciously. It works by delaying the permanent deletion of data by a specified duration, allowing you to retrieve it in 14 additional days.

Nakivo

Naviko is a US-based company specializing in data protection and replication solutions for virtual, physical, cloud, and SaaS environments. They offer a comprehensive suite of tools designed to safeguard your valuable information from various threats, including hardware failures, software corruption, etc.

The features of Nakivo are:

Nakivo offers advanced data replication functionalities, particularly for VMware vSphere environments. It allows you to maintain synchronized copies of your data at multiple locations, minimizing downtime during outages. Depending on your needs, the replication can be done in real-time or on a scheduled basis.
It prioritizes data security features like AES-256 encryption for data at rest and transit, role-based access control to restrict access, and temper-proof backups to prevent unauthorized modifications.

Conclusion

Understanding the differences between data backup vs. replication showcases their distinct roles. They are both essential techniques for safeguarding your valuable information. While they share the common goal of data protection, they cater to different needs and can be achieved in distinct ways. Understanding their strength and ideal use cases helps you choose the optimal approach for your specific situation.

Limitless data movement with free Alpha and Beta connectors

Introducing: our Free Connector Program

The data movement infrastructure for the modern data teams.

Try a 14-day free trial