Exploring Application Integration vs. Data Integration: Key Differences and Use Cases

February 20, 2024
15 mins

When connecting various applications and integrating data across different systems, you'll often encounter two commonly used terms: application integration and data integration. Although these terms sound similar and often interchangeable, they refer to distinct processes with unique benefits and challenges. Understanding the differences between these two techniques is essential to streamlining your business operations effectively.

This article provides a comprehensive overview of application integration vs. data integration, focusing on their differences and various use cases. 

What is Application Integration?

Application integration involves connecting multiple applications to facilitate data and information sharing. This can be achieved using an application programming interface (API) or an integration platform. In API-based integration, each software application provides an API that allows other apps to access its data and functionality. It may be either synchronous or asynchronous, depending on the specific requirements and use cases.

  • Synchronous: Synchronous API-based integration occurs when one application requests another through an API and waits for a response before proceeding. This type of integration is often utilized by real-time applications that necessitate quick data processing, such as e-commerce or financial applications.
  • Asynchronous: In contrast, asynchronous API-based integration involves one application requesting another via an API but not waiting for a response before continuing. This form of integration is commonly used by systems that process data offline, such as CRM or ERP systems.

Integration platforms are another way of connecting two or more software applications efficiently. They provide a middleware layer that enables apps to share data without each application providing an API. Integration platforms often provide a graphical user interface (GUI), allowing you to connect multiple applications seamlessly without writing code.

What is Data Integration?

Data integration is the process of consolidating data from diverse sources into a single unified view. Simply put, it brings together data from various locations, such as databases and data warehouses, to your desired target system. This helps you understand your data holistically by reducing data redundancies and inconsistencies. This, in turn, leads to higher data quality, enabling you to make informed decisions.

Data Integration Approaches

There are different approaches to data integration, including ETL, ELT, and reverse ETL:

ETL (Extract, Transform, Load): It involves extracting data from a source system, transforming it, and ultimately loading it into a destination like a data warehouse or a data lake. The purpose is to ensure that only the transformed data is stored in the target system. 

ELT (Extract, Load, Transform): In this approach, data is extracted from a source system, loaded into a destination, and then transformed. Unlike traditional ETL, where transformations are done before loading, ELT performs transformations at the destination after loading the data. 

Reverse ETL: It is the opposite flow of traditional ETL. Reverse ETL involves extracting data from a destination (such as a warehouse) and sending it back to the source system for analysis or operational use. For example, moving data from Amazon Redshift (data warehouse) to Salesforce (CRM). 

Data Integration vs Application Integration: Key Differences

Understanding the key differences between data integration and application integration is essential to plan, design, and implement integration solutions effectively. Both types of integration have distinct objectives, methodologies, and considerations. 

The fundamental difference between application integration and data integration lies in their respective processes. Application integration focuses on linking multiple applications to facilitate data sharing, whereas data integration aims to combine data from multiple sources into a unified database for a cohesive overview.

For a clearer understanding, let's explore the key differences of data integration vs application integration in a tabular format.

Features Data Integration Application Integration
Definition Combines data from various sources into a unified view Connects different software applications to work together
Purpose Enables better analysis, reporting, and decision-making Streamlines workflows, automates processes
Methods ELT, ETL, Reverse ETL, etc APIs, Middleware, etc
Integration Targets Databases, data warehouses, and data lakes. Enterprise applications, software platforms, and cloud services.
Example Consolidating customer data from multiple databases. Integrating CRM with ERP for seamless data flow.
Key Challenges Data quality and redundancy issues. System heterogeneity and handling diverse APIs.
Complexity More Complex Less Complex
Outcome Unified data structure, and accurate analytics insights. Streamlined operations and enhanced user experience.

When deciding between data integration and application integration, several factors should be considered:

Integration Requirements

  • Data Integration: If you need to move, transform, or manage data.
  • Application Integration: If your goal is to connect and coordinate the functionality of different business applications.

Data Complexity

  • Data Integration: Suitable for managing and updating data structures and schemas.
  • Application Integration: Ideal for managing complex business processes and simplifying them.

Automating Workflows

  • Data Integration: If you want to establish connectivity between databases, data warehouses, and other data sources.
  • Application Integration: Used to automate end-to-end business processes and handle interactions between applications.

Data Sync Requirements

  • Data Integration: When you need to link various data sources.
  • Application Integration: If you require cohesive data flow and synchronized operations.

Application Integration vs Data Integration: Use Cases

Let’s explore the various use cases of Application and data integration:

Application Integration

Here are some common use cases of application integration:

ERP systems: Enterprise resource planning (ERP) acts as a centralized hub for all your business activities. By seamlessly integrating ERP with supporting applications and services, you can streamline and automate critical business processes, such as payment processing,  sales lead tracking, supply chain functions, and numerous other essential functions.

Banking: In banking, application integration is like ensuring all the different software systems the bank uses can work together smoothly. For example, there might be one system for managing customer accounts, another for processing transactions, and another for handling loans. Application integration ensures that these systems can interact with each other and share information seamlessly.

Healthcare: Application Integration can integrate electronic health record (EHR) systems with other healthcare applications. EHR integration allows seamless data exchange between systems, ensuring patient information is accurate, up-to-date, and easily accessible. For example, integrating EHR systems with laboratory information systems enables real-time sharing of test results.

Data Integration

Here are some common use cases of data integration:

Data Migration: Data migration is a crucial use case of data integration, particularly when your business undergoes technology upgrades or platform migrations. It involves transferring data from one system or storage format to another, ensuring that data remains accurate, accessible, and usable throughout the transition process.

Syncing Records: Data integration enables the synchronization of data across different systems. This ensures that the data remains consistent and up-to-date across various platforms, reducing errors and maintaining data integrity.

Business Intelligence: With data integration, you can bring together information from various sources like databases, marketing platforms, and social media channels. This consolidated data becomes the backbone of your business intelligence (BI) and analytics efforts. It allows you to conduct advanced analysis, uncover patterns, and generate actionable insights.

How can Airbyte Help?

Whether you choose to carry out application or data integration, you may encounter certain challenges, such as data compatibility, inconsistencies, and data redundancy. Additionally, you might require technical expertise to get the job done. To overcome this, you can use data integration tools and replication platform like Airbyte to streamline and automate your data pipelines.

Here are the key features of Airbyte:

User-friendly Interface: It provides a seamless experience for users of all skill levels. Its intuitive design simplifies the extraction and loading processes. With Airbyte, you can easily connect to various data sources and APIs and migrate your data to the target system without hassle.

Connectors: Airbyte offers over 350 pre-built connectors, allowing you to transfer data from the source to the destination seamlessly. You can easily choose the required connectors and build the data pipelines without complexity. This streamlined process does not require you to write any code, making it accessible to everyone.

Customization: If you cannot find the connector you need from the pre-existing list, Airbyte offers you the option to create your own custom connector using the Connector Development Kit (CDK). This way, you have the flexibility to build customized connectors to meet your specific requirements.

Change Data Capture (CDC): With Airbyte's Change Data Capture (CDC) technique, you can capture and synchronize data alterations from source systems. This guarantees that the target system is constantly updated with the latest changes.

Transformation: Airbyte follows the Extract, Load, Transform (ELT) approach, which involves loading data from different sources before transforming it. However, it offers seamless integration with dbt (data build tool) for custom transformations.

Wrapping Up

Both application integration and data integration play crucial roles in streamlining your business operations. Understanding the key differences between these two integration methodologies is essential in determining the most suitable approach based on specific use cases. By leveraging the strengths of application integration and data integration, you can achieve seamless connectivity and improved data accessibility.

Limitless data movement with free Alpha and Beta connectors
Introducing: our Free Connector Program
The data movement infrastructure for the modern data teams.
Try a 14-day free trial