All ETL tool comparison

Fivetran vs Talend vs Airbyte

A detailed comparison of Fivetran vs Talend vs Airbyte.

Check the comparison spreadsheet
Fivetran
Fivetran
VS
Talend
Talend
VS
Fivetran
Airbyte

Data analysis and visualization are crucial for determining an organization’s success. To draw actionable insights from datasets, recognize patterns, and formulate suitable strategies, you need to organize and integrate them efficiently. There are several platforms that you can use to perform data integration, transformation, and replication features. Let's go through some of the popular platforms that you can leverage to scale your enterprise needs.

In this article, you will understand the key features of Fivetran vs Talend vs Airbyte and explore the major differences between them.

Fivetran Overview

Fivetran

Fivetran is a cloud-based data integration platform that offers an ELT approach to extracting data from multiple sources and loading it into a target system. Beyond data movement, Fivetran enables data democratization so you can leverage your IT resources for other projects. This capability allows data sharing within your organization without risking data security.

Unique Features of Fivetran

  • By replicating schema changes from the source databases into the destination, Fivetran improves data integration and maintains data consistency throughout the system.
  • Fivetran provides a multitude of deployment choices, including cloud-based, hybrid, and self-hosted, to suit varying requirements for data integration.

Talend Overview

Talend

Talend offers an integrated platform for data management along with data processing, transformation, and integration solutions. Its user-friendly interface and data connection capabilities facilitate quick data pipeline creation. You can leverage these features by accessing Talend suite products like Data Fabric, Stitch Data, the Big Data platform, and Data Management. With these multitudes of applications, you can perform various functions, such as data aggregating, transforming, cleaning, and managing.

Unique Features of Talend

  • Using Stitch Data connectors, you can streamline your integration process by quickly transferring your data to the required destination without any prior technical expertise.
  • Since Talend is a cloud-independent solution, you can seamlessly work across multiple data landscapes, such as cloud, on-premise, multi-cloud, and hybrid data environments.

Airbyte Overview

Airbyte

Airbyte is a cloud-based data integration platform established in 2020. It uses a modern ELT approach to collect data from diverse sources and load it into a destination like a data lake or warehouse. 

With Airbyte, you have the flexibility to build and manage data pipelines in four ways—UI, PyAirbyte, API, and Terraform Provider. While you can employ User-Interface for easy and quick data workflows, the other options are recommended if you have hands-on programming skills.

Unique Features of Airbyte

  • You can employ Airbyte's CDC feature to detect changes made to the source dataset and replicate the changes in the target system. This helps you to monitor and maintain data consistency and integrity.
  • It supports unstructured, semi-structured, and structured data sources, allowing you to adjust to modern data integration workflows.

Airbyte recently released PyAirbyte, a developer-friendly Python library, to enhance its data pipeline development capabilities. Using this library, you can programmatically extract data from the Airbyte-supported connectors.

Fivetran vs Talend vs Airbyte: Key Features

The key features of Fivetran vs Talend vs Airbyte are represented in the table below:

Attributes Fivetran Talend Airbyte
Focus Data movement and transformation Data integration, transformation, and management Data integration and replication
Open Source No No Yes
Number of Connectors 500+ pre-built connectors Varies by service 350+ pre-built connectors
Custom Connectors Function connector Talend Component Kit Connector Development Kit
Database Replication Log-based CDC, log-free replication CDC capabilities Incremental, full, and log-based CDC
Flexibility to build Python Data Pipeline Not available Not available PyAirbyte library
Integration with Data Stack Airflow, Prefect, Dagster, dbt Not available Kubernetes, Airflow, Prefect, Dagster, dbt
Data Transformation dbt Core and Quick Start Data Models Basic to advanced features dbt integration
Community Support 3000+ members Leverages Qlik community 15000+ members
Security Certifications SOC 1, SOC 2, ISO 27001, HIPAA BAA, HITRUST, PCI DSS Level 1 GDPR, CSA STAR, HIPAA, SOC 2 HIPAA, GDPR, CCPA, SOC 2, ISO 27001
Purchase Process Free trial, then custom pricing Custom pricing per product Open source, free and paid plans (trial available)

{{COMPARISON_CTA}}


Fivetran vs Talend vs Airbyte: Major Comparisons

Here’s a detailed comparison of integrations, architecture, and more between Fivetran, Talend, and Airbyte.

Fivetran vs Talend vs Airbyte: Connector Feature

Fivetran has more than 500 connectors in its extensive library. Using these connectors, you can quickly extract and load data from/to multiple sources. In addition, it has a Function connector feature that you can utilize to create a custom connector as an extension of Fivetran. This lets you manage your data pipelines efficiently and extract data from a specific source that Fivetran does not support.

On the other hand, Talend offers a vast library of pre-built connectors across all its products. However, the availability of connectors will depend on which data integration tool you are using from the Talend Studio suite. For instance, using the 47+ source connectors offered by Data Fabric is helpful if you need to move large data volumes. Additionally, you can effortlessly create customized connectors using its Talend Component Kit.

In contrast, Airbyte provides a rich library of 350+ pre-built connectors that you can employ to automate your data pipeline creation in a few minutes. It helps seamlessly integrate data from sources like BigQuery, DynamoDB, and Kafka to different destinations, such as a data lake or warehouse. Apart from existing connectors, you can also build custom ones within 10 minutes using its Connector Development Kit. You can also request a new connector by reaching out to its sales team.

Fivetran vs Talend vs Airbyte: Data Transformation

Fivetran transformations let you maintain data quality and analytical flexibility while organizing, analyzing, and visualizing information. You can perform transformations with its Quick Start Data Models and dbt Core, as both enable complex data modifications with simple SQL queries. While dbt can be employed for cleaning, testing, and transforming datasets, you can use the Quick Start Data Model when you don’t want to build your dbt project. This model allows you to leverage pre-built data models to perform transformations.

Conversely, you can use Talend’s low/no-code environment to perform data transformation and manipulation tasks. It supports both Python and SQL to facilitate data transformation. Using Python codes, you can effortlessly manipulate data based on your needs. You can also write simple SQL queries to perform transformations seamlessly.

Airbyte, on the other hand, allows you to integrate with dbt to support data transformation. You can carry out basic to complex transformations with dbt as it helps you clean and enrich raw data, thus preparing it for analysis and reporting. 

Fivetran vs Talend vs Airbyte: Security and Compliance

Fivetran is dedicated to offering administrative, physical, and technical security to ensure data integrity. Automated hashing and column blocking, user authorization, SSH tunnels, and data encryption are some of the security measures it offers. While hashing protects your Personally Identifiable Information (PII), column blocking allows you to prevent specific tables and columns from being replicated in your destination file. In addition to these safety mechanisms, it complies with industry standards and certifications such as ISO 27001, HIPAA BAA, PCI DSS Level 1, SOC1, and SOC2.

Comparatively, Talend is dedicated to protecting data privacy by adhering to and implementing all policies and procedures into practice. For instance, the Chief Information Security Officer (CISO) at Talend will examine your dataset for external threats and vulnerabilities in a security incident to prevent data loss. This process has six phases—preparation, detection, containment, investigation, remediation, and recovery. Besides these measures, Talend conforms to several industry standards like SOC2 Type 2, HIPAA, GDPR, and CSA STAR.

Airbyte offers various security features to safeguard your data from external threats and vulnerabilities. These preventative measures include credential management, encryption in transit, access restriction, audit logging, and regular security assessments. In addition to these security features, Airbyte complies with all industry certifications and standards, including SOC 2 Type 2, HIPAA, ISO 27001, and GDPR.

Fivetran vs Talend vs Airbyte: Use Cases

With Fivetran, you can integrate and automate data pipelines. In addition to integration, you can use it for data replication, such as log-based CDC and log-free replication, to ensure consistency between systems.

Conversely, Talend is recommended for performing complex data integration tasks. Depending on your specific business needs, you can opt for any suitable plans provided in the Talend suite. Apart from integration, you can also leverage this platform to facilitate data analysis. Using its Customer 360 solution, you can resolve fragmented customer data to achieve a 360-degree view. This helps you to draw actionable insights and deliver customized services to your customers.

On the other hand, Airbyte is an all-in-one solution for various data integration and migration needs. It is highly recommended for handling large datasets cost-effectively. You can utilize Airbyte to build custom data pipelines seamlessly without writing a single line of code. It also allows you to replicate changes made in the source file into the target system using CDC functionality. You can also sync data in batches with a lower syncing frequency duration.

Being open-source in nature, Airbyte empowers you to actively contribute and develop its platform, discuss best integration practices, share resources, and rectify data ingestion queries.

Fivetran vs Talend vs Airbyte: Ease of Use and Implementation

Fivetran offers a simple and intuitive interface that enables you to create fully automated data pipelines within minutes. It requires minimal technical expertise for basic configurations. However, complex data transformations might still require some programming experience.

On the other hand, Talend provides a range of platforms that offer flexibility to perform functions according to your needs, but it might require a learning curve. Though it provides more customization options, the interface can be complex for non-technical users.

In contrast, Airbyte is a suitable platform for both technical and non-technical users. It offers a flexible and intuitive interface that lets you perform data integration in just two steps! However, if you have good programming skills, you can build data pipelines using PyAirbyte, API, and Terraform Provider.

Fivetran vs Talend vs Airbyte: Pricing Process

Fivetran's flexible subscription choices let you pay for the services you use. However, if you have to deal with large datasets, you can choose its paid versions—Starter, Standard, and Enterprise. Each plan is customized to meet different needs depending on the data volume, number of users, and security features.

In contrast, Talend provides distinct paid plans for each product in the Talend suite. Every product has a few standard features, like hybrid/multi-cloud and on-premise integration flexibility, along with some unique ones. You can reach out to their sales team to know more about their paid versions. Apart from these plans, it offers a 14-day free trial to perform data integration for low data volumes.

On the flip side, Airbyte is preferred for its transparent and scalable pricing plans—Airbyte Cloud, Airbyte Self-Managed, and Powered by Airbyte. The Self-Managed version is open-source and, therefore, accessible to everyone. The Cloud version, with its pay-as-you-go model, eliminates the need for server maintenance and management. Lastly, the Powered by Airbyte pricing depends on the syncing frequency duration to perform data synchronization

Which should you Choose?

This article has briefly covered the unique features and detailed comparison between Fivetran vs Talend vs Airbyte. Each platform is equipped with many functionalities and tailored to fulfill your different business needs. While Fivetran is preferable for performing the ELT data integration method, Talend is suitable for leveraging data integration, transformation and management capabilities.

However, we suggest using Airbyte if you want to experience seamless data integration, replication, and transformation on a single platform. Sign in today and navigate its diverse features.

Want to know the benchmark of data pipeline performance & cost?

Discover the keys to enhancing data pipeline performance while minimizing costs with this benchmark analysis by McKnight Consulting Group.

Get now

Compare Airbyte's pricing to other ELT tools

1 minute cost estimator

Don't trust our word, trust theirs!

No items found.

What Airbyte users say

“Airbyte saved us two months of engineering time by not having to build our own infrastructure. We can count on the stability and reliability of Airbyte connectors. Plus, with Airbyte it’s simple to build custom pipelines.”
“With Airbyte, we don’t need to worry about connectors and focus on creating value for our users instead of building infrastructure. That’s priceless. The time and energy saved allows us to disrupt and grow faster.”
"I used Airbyte's connector builder to write 2 connectors. The experience was amazing, the setup was straightforward, and in almost no time I was able to develop a new connector and get it running.”
“Using Airbyte makes extracting data from various sources super easy! I don't have to spend time maintaining difficult data pipelines. Instead, I can use that time to generate meaningful insights from data.”
"Airbyte does a lot of things really well. We just had to set it up, and it ran from there. Even moving 40GB worth of data works just fine without needing to worry about sizing up.”